Someone, I think it was John Lennon, said that opinions are like a certain unmentionable body part – everybody’s got one. Paste recently published a list called The 50 Greatest Beatles Songs, and the word “greatest” got to me, as that implies the writer’s opinion carried some specific gravitas. But opinions are subjective, and so naturally, quite a few of my best-loved songs weren’t on the list.
This is why I stopped writing criticism a long time ago. Opinions are like … well, everybody’s got one.
I have endeavored here to write my own list. Not “greatest” but “the ones I love best.” The Beatles’ music has been near and dear to me since I was maybe 6 years old; it’s been one of the few constants in my life. I think of it as a self-renewing resource, which is why when somebody asks me “Don’t you ever get tired of that stuff?” I just smile. Because I can let it go for a while, but I always come back to it.
I wrote this stream of consciousness, with no notes or reference material. Nos. 50 through 11 are in no particular order. The Top 10 haven’t changed much in all these years.
Here are my favorite Beatles songs. For today, anyway.
- You Can’t Do That (1964)
Maybe it’s the electric 12-string guitar, maybe it’s the invective-laced Lennon lyric, or maybe it’s the chant-like background vocals from McCartney and Harrison, but there’s something ominous about this track that starts with the intro and doesn’t let up before the crawly guitar sting at the very end. Note: “You Can’t Do That” is extremely similar, musically, to the Beatles’ earlier take on Motown’s “Money (That’s What I Want),” so it would seem John and Paul were trying to write their own version (and it always went over great in the live show). Clueless as ever, America’s Capitol Records placed the songs one after the other on its cobbled-together The Beatles’ Second Album.
- Across the Universe (1968)
The Beatles never got a recording of Lennon’s unearthly ode to meditation that met their standards, which explains why it sat in the can for nearly two years. It is one of his sweetest melodies and evocative sets of lyrics. Lennon was never what you could call “godly,” but this blissed-out acoustic song was as close as he got, and without an ounce of sarcasm. Of the versions now available, I prefer the simply-arranged take on Anthology 2.
- Happiness is a Warm Gun (1968)
Whoa there! Lennon’s “White Album” song careens all over the place: First it’s lighthearted poetic whimsy, then gritty blues, then hard rock, then ‘50s doo-wop … somehow, it all flows together and makes some sort of sense. His singing makes the hair stand up on your neck, and the electric guitars have a particularly potent sting.
- Girl (1965)
In all of Lennon’s Rubber Soul songs, his voice has a raspy, world-weary edge; he’s no longer a loveable moptop but a singer and songwriter with something to say. Case in point is “Girl,” a mature narrative (“a man must break his back to earn his day of leisure”) set to a haunting melody and Greek-sounding acoustic instrumentation – and background vocals naughtily chanting “tit-tit-tit-tit-tit.”
- Here There and Everywhere (1966)
Lennon considered this one of McCartney’s finest compositions (McCartney thought so too). It is melodic, evocative and handsome, and up against the nascent trippy-ness and adventuring on Revolver, it stood out like a green thumb – another shining example of McCartney’s way with a pop song. Check out the early take on the Revolver Super Deluxe Edition, with McCartney’s voice before it was double-tracked. It’s heartbreaking.
- Any Time at All (1964)
One of those exhilarating Lennon/McCartney melodies and an optimistic, uplifting lyric (“all you gotta do is call and I’ll be there”). Like many of its mates from the A Hard Day’s Night album, its feeling of bigness comes from the doubling up of piano and guitar in the solo, and the breakneck sincerity of Lennon’s declaration-of-love vocal.
- There’s a Place (1963)
All the cover versions on the album Please Please Me (and the US Introducing the Beatles) are nice enough, as are the handful of Lennon/McCartney originals scattered throughout. But oh, “There’s a Place” is the next level up. John and Paul harmonize like two birds flying in formation, and the song’s message – inside my mind, I can block out the rest of the world – was ahead of its time. It’s a soaring melody that serves the aspirational lyrics beautifully.
- Don’t Bother Me (1963)
Historically little-noticed, George Harrison’s first-ever composition (on the second album, With the Beatles) blasts into the world with pounding rhythm, drums, guitar and bass, and remains in a minor key throughout. It’s a dour tour-de-force, maybe not the greatest lyrics (hey, he’d get better) but a breath of unusually powerful air among the R&B covers and Lennon/McCartney chestnuts on the record.
- A Day in the Life (1967)
A practically perfect pop song, there’s not much left to say about the Sgt. Pepper LP closer. It stands as one of the group’s high-water marks. Between Lennon’s pensive, look-back-with-curiosity lyrics and McCartney’s lofty middle section, it is a compelling narrative. And with George Martin’s apocalyptic orchestral “orgasm of sound” bringing up the rear after Lennon sings “I’d love to turn you on,” it’s one of the era’s quintessential dreamy drug songs. After nearly 60 years, it still chills. And thrills.
- Got to Get You Into My Life (1966)
Revolver’s most uplifting track, bar none. Play it in the car – it’s a great driving song. The brass section gives it power – and initially, the horn lines had been played on electric guitar (the riff is very similar to that on “Paperback Writer” from the same era; McCartney wrote both songs). Someone decided it would sound better with trumpets, saxes and trombones, and boy were they right.
- Long Tall Sally (1964).
This Little Richard raver was a staple of the Beatles’ shows in their club-band days. It showcased McCartney’s screaming-mimi voice (he almost did Richard better than Richard did) and featured Ringo absolutely galloping on the drums. They knew this one so well that it was recorded, live in the studio, in exactly one take. George “Fifth Beatle” Martin played the hammering boogie piano. Anyone who still harbors the old notion that the Beatles weren’t a great live band should give “Long Tall Sally” a good listen.
- We Can Work it Out (1965)
A distillation, in three minutes, of what made the Beatles tower above their contemporaries in 1965. A winsome, pleading vocal from McCartney, set to an impossibly catchy melody, with a chill-inducing harmony middle from Lennon, who plays harmonium.
- You’ve Got to Hide Your Love Away (1965)
Lennon does Dylan, Part 1. The gentle world-weariness in his voice gives meaning to the bittersweet lyric about a love gone cold. It’s all acoustic, with no harmony vocals at all, and at the end – where troubadour Bob would have punctuated his guitar strumming with a harmonica blast – there are twin flutes in harmony.
- Mother Nature’s Son (1968)
Inspired by the words of their (brief) spiritual guide Maharishi Mahesh Yogi, McCartney composed this vivid evocation of someone sitting in a field “singing songs for everyone.” This might be the finest of the acoustic songs on the “White Album,” for its shimmering pastoral beauty. George Martin scored it for an Alpine horn section, which evokes the “mountain stream” McCartney sings about. Inspired by the same Maharishi speech, Lennon wrote the unreleased “Child of Nature.”
- A Hard Day’s Night (1964)
Written (by Lennon) to order as the title song to the first Beatles film, this song springs from the gate with a one-chord explosion from Harrison’s guitar, then barrels along at almost impossible speed. This is pure energy and Beatlemania encapsulated – John takes the verses, Paul the chorus (he always sings the higher parts) and George plays a unique solo on his electric 12-string. Even today, it evokes both the era, and the movie.
- I’m Down (1965)
Proof that McCartney, when he put his mind to it, could write a rocker as good as Little Richard or any other of his musical heroes. “I’m Down” was a B-side (to “Help!”) and never appeared on an album (until much, much later), but they played it at the legendary Shea Stadium show in August of ’65 – the image of an overjoyed Lennon playing the electric piano with his elbow (“I was doing a Jerry Lee”), and making Harrison laugh hysterically, has become part of Beatles lore. Ebullient, fun and defiantly goofy.
- And Your Bird Can Sing (1966)
Lennon considered this Revolver track a “throwaway,” but its soaring melody and close LenMac harmony make it a bright roadflare of mid ’60s Beatles creativity. And those twin lead guitars, playing in perfect harmony, presaged the Allman Brothers Band by several years. “And Your Bird Can Sing” is so breathless, it’s over and out in two minutes.
- The Word (1965)
The word is love, which is, of course, all you need. From Rubber Soul, the ever-maturing Lennon refers to “the good and the bad books that I have read” in the process of discovering his mission (“I’m here to show everybody the light”). “The Word” is a straightforward pop song with a definite message, a balancing act Lennon was perfecting in ’65, and its other selling points are the forward-thrusting structure, the luscious LenMac harmonies and the blistering organ “solo” from Beatles manservant Mal Evans.
- Here Comes the Sun (1969)
The Beatles’ ever-fractious friendship meant that Lennon sat this one out, so it’s just Paul and Ringo helping George put down on tape one of his most-accomplished (and surprisingly, for him, optimistic) songs. “Here Comes the Sun” is a cheery pop song with gorgeous harmony vocals, sections of Indian rhythm (which Ringo took a while to master) and, most significantly, lovely runs of acoustic guitar. The song was composed on a sunny afternoon in Eric Clapton’s garden, whilst George was playing hooky from one of the group’s by then contentious business meetings.
- I Feel Fine (1964)
Deceptively simple, yet a massive achievement in understatement. The lyrics are of no consequence; it’s all about Lennon’s earwormy guitar riff, Ringo’s propulsive drumming and the record’s sense of urgency. A great pop single, no more and no less.
- I’ve Just Seen a Face (1965)
In the UK, McCartney’s jaunty country-flavored track was buried on Side Two of the Help! album, but in America, Capitol Records pasted in onto Rubber Soul later in the year (replacing “Drive My Car”), where it fit marvelously as an acoustic intro to the acoustic and absolutely stunning …
- Norwegian Wood (This Bird Has Flown) (1965)
If there’s one song that signified that change for the Beatles was in the air, it’s “Norwegian Wood,” Lennon’s tongue-in-cheek remembrance of a one-night-stand that didn’t quite go the way he hoped. The waltz-time melody, smoky harmony vocal from McCartney, and Harrison’s sitar work (something new!) doubling Lennon’s acoustic guitar figure was clear indication that an era of fearless experimentation, with both sound and subject matter, had arrived.
- Within You Without You (1967)
A joint effort between the Georges that paid off handsomely and gave the Sgt. Pepper experience a suitably exotic middle section. Mr. Harrison’s lyrics about universal tolerance and understanding – and the lack of it – are sung in almost drone-like fashion on top of traditional Indian instrumentation. But sitar, tabla and tamboura, in a five-minute pop song, can grow a bit tiresome, and that’s where Mr. Martin came in with pizzicato strings, “slurpy” cellos (his description) and violins mimicking and enhancing the eastern instruments. The result: One of the most musically complex, and pleasing, experiments in the Beatles canon.
- Good Night (1968)
John wrote this tender ballad, but wisely gave it to Ringo to sing. The drummer’s plaintive near-croon lent it the air of pathos it needed. It was, also, a masterstroke to place it at the end of the adventure through the looking glass of the “White Album” – a lushly orchestrated, soothing children’s ballad on the heels of the nightmare cacophony of “Revolution 9.”
- I Don’t Want to Spoil the Party (1964).
Bob Dylan’s influence is starting to show, as Lennon attempts an introspective, folk-styled song. Here, he’s abandoning the “I love you” girl-boy subjects of the early Lennon-McCartney lyrics and letting a little vulnerability show. As always, the melody sparkles, and the playing and singing elevate the song to another level. A note: It’s one of the few Beatles recordings where Lennon sings both parts of the two-part harmony; McCartney comes in on the bridge part – “Though tonight she’s made me sad/I Still love her,” one assumes because he could reach the high notes.
- Long Long Long (1968)
Another of George Harrison’s least famous contributions to the canon, this “White Album” track is quiet – the vocal is almost whispered – and moody. It’s all about atmosphere. And it follows the bombastic “Helter Skelter” like the first ray of sunlight after a long and torturous night.
- I’m a Loser (1964)
This is the mate to “I Don’t Want to Spoil the Party,” as composer Lennon looks deep inside himself, declaring he’s nothing but a fraud, and a sad one at that: “Although I laugh and I act like a clown/Beneath this mask I am wearing a frown.” He played harmonica on the track – for the last time – driving home the deeply-felt connection to Mr. Dylan. Both songs appear on Beatles For Sale.
- Hey Bulldog (1968)
The Beatles thought so little of this nonsense-wordplay Lennon track they donated it to the makers of the Yellow Submarine animated film (also the dumping ground for “Only a Northern Song,” “All Together Now” and “It’s All Too Much,” leftovers from the St. Pepper era). Yet it seriously rocks – its famous opening riff played by, in succession, Lennon (piano), Harrison (guitar) and McCartney (bass) until its roars in unison. Great singing from Lennon, too. Note: In America, the “Hey Bulldog” sequence was trimmed from the movie, making purchasers of the soundtrack album wonder why this song was included right there on Side One.
- It Won’t Be Long (1963)
The opening track on With the Beatles, the group’s second album, gallops along without taking a breath. If you want to demonstrate to somebody why the early Beatles were peerless, play them “It Won’t Be Long” – energy and passion and optimism and youthful high spirits – and they’ll never bring it up again.
- In My Life (1965).
An unusually tender set of lyrics from Lennon. It began as a fond look back at the “places I remember” from Liverpool, then expanded to something more universal. McCartney claimed he composed the melody, but the words are all Lennon. Note: I always considered this Rubber Soul track to be the rare example of a poor recording of a great song – it’s just too busy. It’s overdone. Take 1, recently released on Anthology 4, features Lennon’s lead vocal as he sang it in the studio – without double-tracking. McCartney’s harmony is quieter, too. And George Martin’s harpsichord-like piano solo is missing as well. Cut to its essentials, it’s now – to these ears – the definitive version of “In My Life.”
- You Never Give Me Your Money (1969)
McCartney’s sprawling ode to a simpler time (“Oh that magic feeling, nowhere to go”) appeared as the Beatles were scrapping over the future of their ill-conceived Apple Corps, and spending endless hours in business meetings. That’s an unlikely blueprint for a beautifully complex pop song, but he pulled it off – hey, that’s what he does – and so “You Never Give Me Your Money” launches the lengthy Side Two medley of Abbey Road with a flourish.
- Everybody’s Got Something to Hide Except Me and My Monkey (1968)
“Except for the bit about the monkey,” according to Harrison, Lennon wrote this song from words spoken by Maharishi Mahesh Yogi at his mediation retreat in India (“come on is such a joy”). It’s a rhythmically complex rock ‘n’ roll song that sounds like a runaway train that careens back onto the track just at the nick of time. Harrison plays some of his most stinging electric guitar on this “White Album” track.
- Twist and Shout (1963)
One take. With Lennon’s throat already knackered from a full day of recording (nearly the entire Please Please Me album), they saved this Isley Brothers belter for last, because they knew he was going to rip the hell out of his voice. He did, and the world got one of the most iconic rock ‘n’ roll recordings of all time. They did record a Take Two, but the magic was all there on the first attempt, so that’s what we got.
- I’m Looking Through You (1965)
Another jaunty acoustic marvel from McCartney, with harmony from Lennon, for the second side of Rubber Soul. “Michelle” was the big song from this album (although there weren’t any singles released), but “I’m Looking Through You” has such an earworm quality that it could have been a massive hit.
- Dear Prudence (1968)
Lennon’s “White Album” songs, the majority written during the Beatles’ meditation retreat in India, are both tough “(Sexy Sadie”) and tender (“Julia”). This one is pure joy, rendered in the fingerpicking acoustic style he’d learned from Donovan on the retreat, and embellished in the studio by magnificent background vocals and the occasional potent stab from an electric guitar. He’s singing to another meditation student, who kept to her bungalow, to “come out to play” and enjoy communal life in the sunshine. There weren’t a lot of overtly joyous songs coming from the group by 1968, so this one stood out. Quite beautifully.
- Every Little Thing (1964)
The lyrics don’t amount to much – it’s just another “I love you this much” LenMac song – but the Everly Brothers-style harmonies just soar. And it’s a striking melody – they could already knock them out in their sleep.
- You’re Going to Lose That Girl (1965)
There’s a great scene in the Help! movie, showing the Fab Four “in a studio” recording “You’re Going to Lose That Girl.” It’s all faked, of course, but back in the day it was the first time we, the great unwashed, got to see what their working environment must have been like. John singing at one microphone, George and Paul on another doing harmonies, Ringo on drums (and, in a brief cutaway, simultaneously whacking away at a pair of bongos). And it’s a great song, too. That scene in the film plays like a music video in my mind every time I hear it.
- Getting Better (1967)
Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band is best experienced of a piece, as one contiguous program. Many of the songs, of course, work just as well as individual listens. McCartney’s sprightly “Getting Better” is, on the surface, about the author’s attempts at self-improvement (“Man I was mean, but I’m changing my scene”), but it’s at its core just another great melody. It was Lennon, of course, who added the line “It can’t get much worse” following the author’s “I’ve got to admit it’s getting better,” adding a dash of cynicism, as well as another layer of implied symbolism.
- Lucy in the Sky With Diamonds (1967)
Loaded with florid imagery and dreamlike transitions (fast to slow, dark to light), Lennon’s druggy Sgt. Pepper centerpiece is unlike anything else in the catalog. It is a swirling, colorful soundscape that conjures beautiful pictures in the mind.
- It’s Only Love (1965)
Lennon professed no love for this potent acoustic number, from the UK Help! album. In America, it was tacked onto Rubber Soul, where it somehow fit right in and made utter sense as the lead-in to his world-weary ballad “Girl.”
- Ask Me Why (1962)
A very early example of Lennon and McCartney “breaking the mold” with a song that’s not quite rock ‘n’ roll, and not quite a sappy ballad. Three-part harmonies carry the melody. This is one I sang to my children when they were little (“I love you ‘cause you tell me things I want to know”), so it always brings me to a happy time.
- Tomorrow Never Knows (1966)
The moment, timestamped, where the Beatles went warp-speed ahead of everybody else. Inspired by LSD proponent Timothy Leary’s take on the Tibetan Book of the Dead, its heavy metaphysical lyrics are sung by Lennon, who wrote the song, over a single-chord drone and hypnotic drum pattern. If it had ended there, “Tomorrow Never Knows” would today be just a curiosity in the catalog. But the Beatles (and George Martin) mixed in freaky tape loops, backwards guitar and – most importantly for the song structure – an occasional modulation from C to B flat, which help created a melody where there hadn’t been one. A most successful experiment in sound.
8. The Inner Light (1968)
They gave George his first B-side with this lilting number, recorded with Indian musicians during the Bombay sessions for his Wonderwall movie-soundtrack. The lyrics were taken directly from the Buddhist Tao Te Ching. It’s an outlier in the Beatles canon, and one of the very last tracks to be included on an album (Rarities in 1978). “The farther one travels, the less one knows.”
7. I Am the Walrus (1967)
In the book An Illustrated Record, Roy Carr and Tony Tyler called this song “downright peculiar,” and I’ve always considered that the perfect descriptor. The lyrics are a rambling series of disconnected images, the music odd, angular and loping. George Martin wrote perhaps his most appropriate Beatles score, ever, with swooping cellos and violins, foxhunt horns and bits of “Greensleeves” and “In the Mood” at the fade. Often mistakenly referred to as psychedelia, “I Am the Walrus” is either the postscript to Sgt. Pepper or the first notes of what was yet to come. Taken as a whole, it’s nightmare-as-pop-song, and considering it was created just five years after “Love Me Do,” it stands as one of the group’s finest achievements.
6. For No One (1966)
McCartney’s second killer ballad on Revolver echoes baroque music, with its harpsichord-like piano and melancholy French Horn solo. “For No One” chronicles a love gone bad from the man’s point of view; wistful and sad, it is achingly beautiful and a worthy ornament on the shining Revolver tree.
- Martha My Dear (1968)
Somewhere along the way, McCartney taught himself to play more than easy chords and boogie on the piano. “Martha My Dear” – yes, she was his Old English sheepdog – is bouncy, and fun, and George Martin’s tasteful strings-and-horn arrangement gives it the feeling of taking place in an English garden at teatime. And sequencing was never more important – on the “White Album,” “Martha My Dear” comes right after Lennon’s exhausting (but equally brilliant) “Happiness is a Warm Gun.”
- I’ll Be Back (1964)
On Anthology 1, we can eavesdrop on Lennon and McCartney trying this melancholy tune in waltz time. Clearly, it didn’t work, and they changed the time signature appropriately to what we’re all familiar with. There are dozens of Beatles songs with their close harmonies at the fore, but many don’t connect emotionally with the impact of this acoustic A Hard Day’s Night LP closer. In the States, we got it on the hybrid album Beatles ’65.
- Hey Jude (1968)
The longest single (7:11) released up to that time, by anyone, McCartney’s “Hey Jude” was chosen to launch Apple Records, the Beatles’ boutique label – and there could not have been a better choice. It’s an epic audio experience from start to finish, a gorgeous melody, hopeful lyric and a singalong fadeout that lasts a full five minutes. Only the Beatles could have pulled that off. And it became their best-selling single of all.
- She Said She Said (1966)
Inspired by an LSD-fueled comment from actor Peter Fonda, who’d died on the operating table as a child (he was resuscitated), “She Said She Said” is another seemingly nonsensical Lennon lyric with propelling guitar riffs and harmonies by none other than George Harrison (McCartney was not present at the overdubbing session). Some of Lennon’s finest singing, and another indicator that he was beginning to look inward (“When I was a boy, everything was right”). Another sequencing masterstroke, too: On Revolver, it launches after the slight (and more or less inconsequential) “Yellow Submarine.”
- Strawberry Fields Forever (1966)
On a personal note, this has been my go-to Beatles song since I can’t remember. From the haunting opening notes (played on the mellotron, an early kinda-synthesized keyboard, on the “flute” setting) to the freak-out coda, it’s a wonder, a marvel, a magical mystery tour of sound, sight, mood and color. Although Lennon’ slowed-down vocal takes a bit of getting used to (check out Take 4, on the Sgt. Pepper Super Deluxe edition, to hear him singing it normally – it’s chilling). “Strawberry Fields Forever” was written in Spain, while Lennon was shooting a movie, and its central deeply nostalgic image is of an orphanage near his boyhood home in Liverpool. Add to the imagery George Martin’s superlative scoring of cellos and brass, and you have one of the Beatles’ crowning achievements.

“I like to just start talking with people,” Cole says. “I walked out, and that cop was sitting there in that police car. I just started carrying on a conversation with him. I was asking him about all kinds of things, about the city of London and the traffic control, things like that. Passing the time of day.
What does it say about the Beatles’ seemingly bottomless well of inspiration that their most creative and cohesive album, full of dash, daring, musical innovation and a brilliant explosion of unexpected colors, came packaged in an austere, black and white jacket with a simple line drawing of their four famous faces and a single word – Revolver, the title of the album?

“I like to just start talking with people,” Cole says. “I walked out, and that cop was sitting there in that police car. I just started carrying on a conversation with him. I was asking him about all kinds of things, about the city of London and the traffic control, things like that. Passing the time of day.